im not a fan of the cover. i find it distasteful and lacking vocal precision. just saying. I love ash and i think her song is much better than this.

this was terrible… just sayin’.

horrible

Horrible more horrible!! Somebody tell her to SHUT UP!! i love miley but THİS İS SUCK!!!

Of coors Ash is my Very Favourite singer, but I like Miley too. I like to listen Ash’s version more, but I really like Miley’s version too. Miley has a bit more attitude , I think And it’s not horrible, Miley is very, very good singer at live. Of coors I think that Miley shoult stay for country, cause she is so much better at that. I’m huge fan of Ash but I think Miley is better in live than Ash ( not only “kicking and screaming”). Anyway I LIKE BOTH VERSIONS!

Btw, sorry for my English, it’s not my mother toung

I think it’s great. Very cool that she must be an Ashlee fan. Great tribute to Ashlee’s style.

uggggggggg this just pisses me off!!!!!!!!!!!!! don’t copy ash!! miley sings horrible why can she make her own songs??

No. Just no.

its really neat to see all the ashleefans get so angry at miley and call her talentless and act like she is butchering a classic here. ashlee is in no way a better musical “artist” than miley. they are both abominations. sorry.

@ thom yorke shut the h*ll up!
at least ashlee can write her own music and that just makes her an artist

Ashlee is way better than miley. Not once has she tried to be something she’s not. I hate miley cyrus so much, she ruined a great song! This is just awful!

i really do not like her version, this song has the sassy attitude of ashlee simpson that miley cannot pull. i still don’t know why it wasn’t on the album in the US this is a great song. after i saw this i had to listen to ashlee’s version. i hope in the future she will tour again she is a great perform

Why did she have to cover it? I feel bad, I don’t think I’ll ever be able to listen entirely to Miley’s cover, ‘cuz my ears always start bleeding before it is over. Seriously. It’s almost disrespectful. I hate Miley. She can’t sing at all, she can’t act at all and she just irritates me. If only she’d stuck to her OWN annoying music…

I listened to the recorded version of this today, and it isn’t half bad. A little whiney, but not horrible. She just shouldn’t sing it live.

hey thom, if your no fan of ashlee than why the hell are you always on here commenting away? i just find it illogical and quite pathetic of you.

hahaha hey “THOM” yes we’re fans.. but we are honest, and pleasee this is not for miley she can even get a little of this great song, she arruined it.. accepted it. this cover suuucks, her voice is horrible and trying to “scream” like ash hahaha i feel sorry, why she always has to cover??

how many covers has miley done? this would be her 4th?

hey ashlee fans everybody in youtube said miley’s better but the real thing is ashlee’s more better!!! i hate miley horrible singing..the original is more BETTER!

cuz youtube’s full of morons loool
hello? its prolly her fans

Okay, everyone’s forgotten what wasn’t mention. She just basically screaming at the times. She can breathe correctly at times in the song. And she dances like she having a seizure. Plus she can’t even scream right like Ash’s orginal. Plus she offended my race earlier this year too. More reasons to hate no talent Miley.
P.S. Saying this, I thought Selena Gomez and the Scene should’ve covered it. I heard her latest song “Falling Down” and it sounds like an Ashlee song (And a lot of people on IMDB boards on the Sel boards said that too!)

Hmm, she is even acting like Ashlee… I wonder what will be the next Ashsong she wannal cover ? maybe Pieces Of Me lol

Just saying, i agree with sandra. And omg i hated miley before, now i hate her even more, wth was she thinking, its terrible, she is murdering the song ang aaahh its really quite bad, Ashlee sings it a million times better

I like ashlee’S version more, but only because I think her voice fits the song better. but miley did a good job. But I think Ashlee’S voice has this raspy and sassy tone. And that’s what I like

I wish Ashlee performed it

the reason why miley is famous because of hanna montana aired on disney channel all oh her fans 90% 8 ~ 16 years old .. even gayness brothers are the same

MILEY IS SOOOOOOOOOOOOOO MUCH BETTER!!!
I LOVE ASHLEE BUT SHE CAN’T SING LIVE!!!
MILEY IS THE BEST!!
AND BTW THEY ARE REALLY GOOD FRIENDS AND U R SOO STUPID TO HATE MILEY!!!

Not trying to stir the pot Ash, but HAVE you ever seen her perform LIVE? I have at a Jimmy Kimmel taping. I’m sorry but Viley tries to so hard, and she fails as a performer. And why is it stupid to hate Miley, it’s our opinion, so if you can’t deal w/ that go back to your Slutty Cyrus boards. Let’s see, Viley takes inapproriate pics both private and in magazines, made fun of my ethinicity, danced like a stripper on national TV on a show geared toward teens, Yeah, I guess it’s stupid to hate Miley, when Ashlee has not done all of these!

to Ash: yeah, maybe. but when Ash is friend with miley, must it mean for us that we can´t hate miley? OMG
I just say, that miley sing this song horrible, because her voice is very horrible for this song, and ashlee´s voice is great for this song.
and Ash can performs live. she´s great.

but it´s your and my different opinion. i don´t say, that you must hate miley, when i hate miley. everybody have their opinion. and it´s really good, i just say that is idiocy, that we can´t hate miley…

silly miley…:(

@ash At least Ashlee sings live. Miley doesn’t. FAIL

I don’t h8 Miley’s version… It’s ok…. Ashlee is better… but Miley do it ok….. anyway, Miley likes Ashlee’s style and that’s cool….

anything to promote ashlees music miley knows how great it is its a compliment hopefully this might give ash incentive to get back in the studio n get back to music cant wait!

MILEY IS BETTER LIVE LMAO!!!
don’t compare Roxie Hart (ashlee simpson) to hanna (miley) ashlee rocks chicago and she rocks live more than miley .. what a joke wasting my time to comment for 5 ~ 8 years old kids

@ ASH- AT LEAST ASHLEE SIMPSON WROTE THE SONG!!!!!!! SHE CAN SING IT BAD IF SHE WANTS TO
NOW BUH-BYEEE

and @ OLDEST FAN- what’s your ethnicity?

I agree w/ Koko – At least Ashlee has been stage, I’d like to see if Miley can do a play on stage – I bet not

@princess – I don’t know if Ashlee will get to the studio, since she’s busy w/ MP. I think by default it will be a hit , so she probably will be busy w/ it for a least 2 or more years. And she wants to raise Bronx when he still an infant.

@May – Japanese-American. If you didn’t know, there was a leaked private pic of Miley and her friends making a face gesture mocking Asians in January. Yeah some role model Miley is to my students!

WTF? Again?
Miley….pls stop copy Ashlee!!!!

honestly, I don’t think it’s a bad cover. ashlee’s better, because it’s usually almost impossible to make a song better than who originally created the song. but at the same time I don’t think miley meant to try and be better than ashlee. she’s an ashlee fan just like all of us, and if I were famous I would have covered ashlee too.

that being said, this song is actually pretty good for miley’s voice. they both hit low notes really well. and she’s getting ashlee great publicity.

@chela i think that miley´s fans won´t matter, who wrote tis song and who sing this song before her…

this sucks so badly…

http://www.iesb.net/extensions/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=7391:interview-ashlee-simpson-takes-up-residence-at-melrose-place&catid=44:interviews&Itemid=172

A question???? is Ashlee the owner of this song????? I think the song is a cover right????? o_O (confused)

@Jc WenTz yes, it is but ashlee told miley that she can use this song…